First on the Teamsheet: The Five Falcons Making Themselves Impossible to Drop
Autumn at the Falcons has not been a smooth ride. There have been afternoons when the wind has done its best to ruin things, evenings when the bench has looked thinner than a January wallet, and more than a few spells when the faithful have wondered which version of the side would turn up. Yet through the stop-start rhythm of the past two months, five players have quietly made themselves very difficult to leave out.
This is not a list of the flashiest names or the loudest voices. It is a list of the players whose work has become the scaffolding around the rest of the XI. The sort of contributions you notice more when they are missing. And with injured bodies returning and the festive pile-up creeping closer, the manager has a proper — and welcome — selection headache.
1. Danny Kerr – the keeper who made the gloves his own
When the season began, Danny Kerr was the understudy. Polite, patient, the kind of goalkeeper who warms up with the same intensity whether he is starting or watching. Then came the injury to the No.1, and Kerr got his run.
Since mid-September he has started six matches and kept four clean sheets. More importantly, he has changed the mood in front of him. Kerr is not a goalkeeper who makes the spectacular save for the highlights reel and then flaps at a cross; he is calm, decisive, and loud enough to organise a back line that has sometimes needed organising. Against the division's most direct side last month, he came for three early crosses and took the sting out of the game before it could properly start.
The Falcons faithful have noticed. 'He just makes everything feel less chaotic,' one regular on the east terrace said after the last home win. That is not a statistic you will find on a spreadsheet, but it is exactly why Kerr is now first on the teamsheet. The returning No.1 may have a fight on his hands, and that is no bad thing.
2. Liam Struthers – the centre-half who never panics
Liam Struthers does not look like a player who enjoys a quiet life. He is the sort of centre-half who will throw himself in front of a shot, then dust himself down and ask for another. But the quality that has stood out this autumn is not the last-ditch stuff; it is the composure.
In his last eight starts, Struthers has won 11 of 14 aerial duels and been dribbled past only twice. He is not the quickest defender in the league, and he knows it. So he reads the game, steps across, and uses his frame cleverly. When the Falcons have had to defend a lead, he has been the one organising the line, pointing, cajoling, and heading away the danger.
There was a moment in the away draw at the end of October that summed him up. Deep in stoppage time, with the hosts loading the box, Struthers did not panic or dive in. He stood his ground, let the attacker take a heavy touch, and calmly shepherded the ball out for a goal kick. It was not a highlight. It was exactly the sort of thing that wins you points.
3. Cal Menzies – the midfielder who covers every inch
Every team needs a player who does the running nobody else wants to do. For the Falcons this autumn, that player has been Cal Menzies. The midfielder has started every league match since the first week of September, and there are afternoons when it feels like he has covered every blade of grass twice.
Menzies is not the most eye-catching passer in the squad. He is not the one who threads a 40-yard ball through a needle. What he does is knit things together. He takes the ball under pressure, turns away from trouble, and gives the more creative players the platform to play. Off the ball, he is relentless. He presses, recovers, and covers for full-backs who have pushed forward.
The numbers back it up: no Falcons player has made more interceptions this autumn, and only one has covered more ground. But the real evidence is in the crowd's reaction. When Menzies went down with cramp against the league leaders, the groan around the ground was audible. He is the sort of player you only truly appreciate when he is not there.
4. Ruairi Sharp – the winger who does the ugly side
Ruairi Sharp has always been capable of the spectacular. The stepovers, the burst of pace, the cross whipped in with the outside of the boot. What has changed this autumn is everything else. The tracking back. The pressing. The willingness to take a kick and get up again.
Sharp has contributed three goals and four assists since the start of October, but it is his work without the ball that has made him undroppable. In the last home fixture, he made more tackles in his own half than any other player on the pitch. He won two penalties in October with direct running, and he has become a reliable out-ball when the Falcons are under pressure.
Supporters have warmed to him because he looks like he cares. There was a moment in the second half last Saturday when he sprinted 40 yards to close down a goalkeeper and forced a rushed clearance into touch. The east terrace loved it. So did his manager. When a winger with that much talent decides to do the boring bits, you keep him in the side.
5. Euan Baird – the striker who makes the team breathe
Euan Baird has not scored in every game this autumn. In fact, there was a run of four matches without a goal that had some supporters muttering. But watch the Falcons play without him and the difference is obvious. Baird is the focal point. He holds the ball up, wins fouls, and gives his team-mates time to join the attack.
His goal return — five in all competitions — is respectable rather than spectacular. But his value is in the details. He has won more free-kicks in the attacking third than any other Falcons player. He has laid on three assists with clever flicks and knockdowns. And he has run himself into the ground for the cause, often chasing lost causes in the 88th minute when the game is already won.
The supporters' debate about Baird is one of the healthiest at the club. Some want a poacher through the middle. Others point to the way the team plays better when Baird is leading the line. For now, the evidence says he stays. The festive run will need a striker who can absorb pressure and bring others into play. Baird does that better than anyone else at the club.
The selection headache nobody minds
Here is the thing about players becoming undroppable: it is only a problem if you let it be one. The Falcons have a squad, not a fixed XI, and the festive period will demand rotation. Injuries will happen. Form will dip. The manager will need to make calls that upset someone.
But the five names above have earned the right to be at the front of the queue. They have done it quietly, without fuss, and with the sort of consistency that turns a decent autumn into a platform. The faithful can debate the finer points over a pint — and they will — but the case for each is strong.
The real test comes now. The nights are drawing in, the pitches are getting heavier, and the festive fixtures are stacking up. If the Falcons are going to make this season count, they will need the quiet five to keep doing what they have been doing. On current evidence, that is exactly what will happen.